VNC replacement for screensharing
Sorry to resurect this very old thread but with your recent announcement of "Enhanced Wayk Now Sessions on Windows" I'm still unsure whether I can share the same physical session onto multiple RDP clients as VNC would do?
Screen sharing for multiple remotes
Thank you, Marc-André, for asking. These subtle differences are actually what makes it so hard to find a VNC alternative - you wouldn't know from the description on the website ... so yes, I mean "the same user session accessed by multiple users at the same time".
Screen sharing for multiple remotes
Hi,
I was once looking for an alternative to VNC because we would need the ability to have multiple admins logging in into a shared (virtual) PC. I'm still using VNC but it is slow and a CPU hog on the virtual PC. And I haven't found a good alternative to VNC, although we would be willing to pay a reasonable license.
So please, once you have implemented "service mode", also consider "screen sharing from multiple remote admins" as a feature.
VNC replacement for screensharing
Hi all,
we're currently using VNC for sharing the console screen to several users. That works okay with RDMs default and UltraVNC implementations, except that VNC is a real CPU hog (on the server) and the session tends to hang whenever there's a glitch on the line.
My question to all of you (i.e. including users) is therefore:
Do you know an alternative to VNC, that
- does screen sharing (aka console sharing)
- reconnects automatically and reliably after a (short) line failure
- does not hog the server CPU
- does not consume too much bandwidth
- and, most importantly, is among the types support by RDM
RDP would be the ideal choice except I don't see how we can share the *same* screen with RDP to multiple users some of them view-only, some read-write. I don't know any of the other types supported by RDM, though, and would be happy to get your recommendations.
default VNC on W2003 64-bit fails to start
Hi,
it's been quite a long time since I've found a real bug in 11.1, but this seems to be one:
I've created a VNC session in default mode. That works fine on a Windows 7 workstation. On my W2003R2 64-bit server (which I still use as a workstation) the default VNC will ..... and will add two entries to the application log:
System.Threading.ThreadAbortException: Thread was being aborted.
at Devolutions.RemoteDesktopManager.Business.HttpBrowserLinker.c36e11a71b2027cacbbca5f70b6ed33df()
at System.Threading.ExecutionContext.Run(ExecutionContext executionContext, ContextCallback callback, Object state, Boolean ignoreSyncCtx)
at System.Threading.ExecutionContext.Run(ExecutionContext executionContext, ContextCallback callback, Object state)
at System.Threading.ThreadHelper.ThreadStart()
and
System.DllNotFoundException: Unable to load DLL 'DevolutionsARD': The specified module could not be found. (Exception from HRESULT: 0x8007007E)
at Devolutions.Ard.ARDNativeAPI.CreateContext(String host, Int32 port, String username, String password)
at Devolutions.Ard.ArdCustomControl.Connect(String host, Int32 port, String username, String password)
at Devolutions.RemoteDesktopManager.Frames.Embedded.FreEmbeddedAppleRemoteDesktop.Connect()
Also a popup appears, but only once after starting RDM (i.e. not when I try again from the same RDM instance) which says:
Entry Point Not Found
The procedure entry point GetTickCount64 could not be located in the dynamic link library KERNEL32.dll.
This happens on both 32 and 64 bit versions of RDM 11.1. UltraVNC mode (instead of default) works, though.
Inconsistent view/edit permissions on sub-connections
Hello Hubert,
this hasn't changed in 11.1.0. But 11.1 may have been released already when you posted, and "next version" is in a 11.1.x beta? I'll check the behavior again when I upgrade and will keep you updated.
[SUBMIT] autofill browser login broken in 11.0.24
Just to confirm: Works as you said in 11.1.0 with the power of the mighty legacy click ;-)
popup shows last action, not current
Sorry, I really don't know how would call that popup that appears shortly when you do refactoring or when RDM pings multiple IPs (if specified) when opening a new session.
This popup always shows the previous action, not the current one. Example: When I do a refactoring action (un/parenting a connection) and then open a device that has multiple IPs (checked by pinging) it will say it is now refactoring. When I then open the next multi-IP device, it says it would be pinging the device opened before, and so on.
If you want me to, I can provide a video but it might be hard to catch because the popup appears so briefly.
This is with RDM 11.0.24 on a Windows 7 PC with the UI style set to classic in case it matters.
[SUBMIT] autofill browser login broken in 11.0.24
Hi David,
thank your for investigating. I will PM you because all our devices are on private IP addresses and the only public URL we had added before (that fails now) is operated by German Telekom for coordination of phone number transfers.
Precedence of local and user specific settings
It seems that when I apply both user specific and local specific settings, the user specific settings will take precedence. I'm not sure I like that but that obviously depends on other potential use cases ... my use case is this:
When I open a Hyper-V console from my machine to my machine, I get this error:
System.Management.ManagementException: User credentials cannot be used for local connections
at System.Management.ManagementException.ThrowWithExtendedInfo(ManagementStatus errorCode)
at System.Management.ManagementScope.InitializeGuts(Object o)
at System.Management.ManagementScope.Initialize()
at Devolutions.RemoteDesktopManager.Managers.ThreadManager.c348e783a1781e2653839d7d29c0ac214.c5270d6ea4265a9815d5d11ab0b681b22()
at Devolutions.RemoteDesktopManager.Managers.ThreadManager.cb336acd3438bdd362a289ff64cbf1ba3.c0d9783525d3185e81614d3643ffc1222(Object c0f3a9f21384dc89d2ff3a4ac11b9d047)
I tried to fix this by applying local specific credentials that are set to embedded <none>, effectively applying no credentials - and the error went away. However, when I apply user specific credentials at the same time (for when I'm working on another PC) they take precedence and the error reappears. So in my case, it would be nice if local specific settings were preferred.
Is Windows 2008 Hyper-V supported for RDP and Console?
Ha! That guest was me. Your forum keeps logging me out before I can put my thoughts into proper English. Most of the times I loose all my work when that happens. This time my post appeared as Guest, which is better but probably won't work in all sub-forums. The real solution would be to lengthen the timeout for foreigners, please please :-)
Is Windows 2008 Hyper-V supported for RDP and Console?
Oh wait. I've tried to implement my Hyper-V RDP session in a sub-connection. If I "unparent" that sub-connection and apply my user-specific access credentials, the connection to a Hyper-V virtual machine starts working. I will investigate whether that is a question of wrong credentials or something else.
Is Windows 2008 Hyper-V supported for RDP and Console?
I got a Windows 2008 R2 server that also acts as a Hyper-V server. I'd like to connect to a virtual machine with RDP (using Hyper-V embedded mode) and that fails. The docs only tell about Hyper-V v2 on Windows 2012 R2 but not whether v1 is supposed to work with Windows 2008 R2 - or only on Windows 2012, where I got it to work nicely.
So before I try further - should Hyper-V RDP (and the Hyper-V Console session type) work Windows 2008 R2?
Inconsistent view/edit permissions on sub-connections
Not sure the subject does describe it appropriately, also not sure this is a bug or a feature :-)
Let's say I have a parent node P where access permissions are applied. Beneath P, I have a node N for an RDP session with security inherited from P. As my effective permissions on P are set to View-only, when I try to edit N, RDM will tell me that I don't have edit permissions. Good.
Now if there is a sub-connection S beneath N which inherits access permissions from P (via N), I can open S for editing (CTRL-E or Properties) and change settings for S. I can even click OK after changing S. Then, RDM will let me do the same for properties of N because it opened the settings dialog for N behind S. Only when I click OK on N will it tell me that I don't have edit permissions.
I'm not sure whether P is required in this scenario or the same would happen if access permissions would be applied to S directly (I'm just describing my setup). To me, this appears like a security hole - any user who can see N can look into properties of S and N, although he can't change anything at the end.
non-modal shared templates list
While working around the SUBMIT bug, I had to switch back and forth between the session tree and my shared templates. So I came to wish that the shared templates would be a non-modal dialog that I wouldn't have to close and re-open so many times, or better yet, a floating/dockable UI view.
Background: I'm using the Host + linked Template concept a lot in my growing setup. Due to the many subtle differences in browser login forms on the various devices that we manage, there are a lot of templates to maintain now.
[SUBMIT] autofill browser login broken in 11.0.24
I've upgraded my installation to 11.0.24 this morning and found that all my browser sessions configured for auto-login with IE embedded didn't work anymore, if [SUBMIT] was used originally. I've upgraded from 11.0.21, so that regression must have occurred in between.
I was able to "repair" some of them now by replacing [SUBMIT] with [ENTER], but not all. Also, if the "login button ID" required an HTML element ID (i.e. neither were SUBMIT nor ENTER working originally), that ID no longer works in 11.0.21, and ENTER and SUBMIT don't work either. So I'm left with a couple of session which fail to log on with 11.0.24.
In all cases the login form fields (username and password) are being filled correctly. It's only the final SUBMIT that doesn't work. Of course, as a workaround, we can click the login button manually :-)
Inconsistent behavior of $HOST$ in shared template
Many thanks!
This works fine now, both with TELNET and Browser sessions, and not only with the $HOST$ variable but with $HOST_WITHOUT_DOMAIN$ variable too. The latter is the one I was really interested in because it permits me to have the Host session prompt for the host name, strip any domain part a user may have appended, and add the correct domain suffix in the linked template.
Host type: show linked template(s)
Found the list of linked templates on the new "Action" tab in 11.0.24. Looks great. Many thanks!
Inconsistent behavior of $HOST$ in shared template
Sorry, Sebastien, somehow this topic wasn't sending notifications to me anymore (although I'm still subscribed). I'm now on 11.0.24 and will try once quickly - because I'm unsure whether "next version" refers to beta or official - and will report back afterwards.
11.0.20 32bit version crashes on exit on W2003R2
No "crash on exit" on W2003R2 experienced with 11.0.24 32bit version anymore. Thank you for the fix!
minor: Session-type custum icon reverts to default on next edit
Your fix was probably included in 11.0.21. I've verified it in 11.0.24 now. Many thanks!
Sort priority change rendered treeview empty
Hi Stefane again,
promised feedback: I've now used the OpenMCDF engine in 11.0.20 and 21 (now 24) and never experienced a problem anymore. I've even used 4 data sources, switching back and forth to verify effective permission settings. So, as you said, this engine seems to be a good fix when working with multiple data sources.
On another PC, I've kept the Default (SQLite) setting but disabled the caching in the Advanced tab for all Data Sources. That also prevented problems in the 18, 20, and 21 versions and seems to be a workaround for those who want to keep 11.0.18 until the next official release.
User Interface Does Not Work in 11.0.19.0!!!!!!
With 11.0.24 I can confirm that the classic UI works again. Thanks for the fix!
How to prevent users from adding user specific session credentials
Many thanks in advance, David.
It will be interesting to see where RDM 12 is heading with respect to a "kiosk mode" for less privileged colleagues. In the meantime, I've spotted a couple of things that should be invisible in that scenario too, like the "dangerous" options available in the "open with parameters" context menu and dashboard, that allow picking other credentials or templates.
Basically, in that kiosk mode for colleagues, I'd like them to be able to use what I specify (in terms of credentials and templates) and not something they could invent on their own to gain higher level access. It's not that I wouldn't trust them, but an ISO27001 auditor should not.
On that level, it would be helpful (maybe, depending on your concept for RDM 12) if access permissions could be applied to shared templates. Other thoughts on this:
** Maybe make shared templates visible in the navigation tree so that access permissions can be applied to them and/or they are only valid in a certain sub-tree, like credentials.
** Maybe user View permissions should be split into "application can use it" and "user can view it". This could be helpful for other scenarios as well, i.e. to hide away credentials nodes while still permitting their use. And it could/should prevent users from copying templates from shared to local, which currently works although they cannot view (or edit/add/delete) them directly in the shared location.
That being said, I wish you good luck with your improvements of the security system in RDM 12 ... :-)
Host type: show linked template(s)
Great! Thank you very much for making the linked template visible. The report is just an extra ... like having a batch edit to change the underlying template in Host sessions ;-)