Smart Reconnect as a Default Not Working

I've done multiple batch edits and many single edits on a handful of Windows 2012 and 2008 servers that I use on a daily basis using the settings you see attached in the screen shot.

In spite of these settings, they all recently started to either or both a) open in External full screen, and upon hitting Restore, b) have scrollbars even though Smart Reconnect is set for the server's profile.

I did the batch edit and set the session template defaults as recommended here:

https://forum.devolutions.net/topic28128-enable-smart-reconnect-by-default.aspx

I've been fighting this for days and now I'm frustrated that I haven't been able to find the right settings to make things work the way they have been up until this last week.

I'm willing to uninstall and reinstall (haven't yet) if you think that will fix it, or if there is some kind of profile rebuild/reset I can do, I'm desperate to not have every connection require 5 extra steps to get the display correct every time I pull up a server.

My machine is a Surface Pro 4 (with high DPI) recently updated (couple weeks ago) to Creators Update for what that's worth. DPI settings for sessions on the Surface alone changed but I don't think the settings I'm fighting started annoying me until this last week.

Thank you!